Using Boundary Objects to Co-Create Community Health and Water Knowledge with Community-Based Medical Anthropology and Indigenous Knowledge

Keywords: Indigenous knowledge; community-based methods; biocultural health; water governance and health; environmental determinants of health; co-creating knowledge

Abstract

This article explores how Indigenous Knowledge and medical anthropology can co-construct community health knowledge through boundary work and the use of boundary objects. It will highlight how community-based participatory research (CBPR) in medical anthropology can help co-develop methods and strategies with Indigenous research partners to assess the human health impact of the First Nations water crisis. We draw on a case study of our community-based approach to health research with Six Nations of the Grand River First Nation community stakeholders and McMaster University researchers. We highlight how framing a co-constructed health survey as a boundary object can create dialogical space for Indigenous and western academic pedagogies and priorities. We also explore how this CBPR anthropology approach, informed by Indigenous Knowledge, allows for deeper foundations of culturally centered health to guide our work in identifying current and future community health needs concerning these ongoing water contamination and access issues. Through three health survey versions, priorities and research questions shifted and expanded to suit growing community health priorities. This led to collaborative action to communicate specific messages around water contamination and access across governance, community, and institutional boundaries. We demonstrate how our co-constructed approach and boundary work allows for the respectful and reciprocal development of these long-term research partnerships and works in solidarity with the Two-Row Wampum (Kaswentha) treaty established by the Haudenosaunee Nation and European settler nations. 

Author Biographies

Sarah Duignan, McMaster University

is a Ph.D. candidate in medical anthropology at McMaster University, Hamilton, ON. Her research interests are exploring the relationships between holistic health and water security using a biocultural approach. She is the coordinator of the community health assessment team for Co-Creation of Indigenous Water Quality Tools. Email: duignase@mcmaster.ca 

Tina Moffat, McMaster University

is an associate professor of anthropology at McMaster University. Her main area of interest is nutrition and food insecurity as it relates to the social, cultural, and physical environment. Her research perspectives are grounded in biocultural and political-economic approaches. She is the Co-Investigator for Co-Creation of Indigenous Water Quality Tools. 

Dawn Martin-Hill

(Mohawk Nation, Wolf Clan) is an associate professor with appointments in the Department of Anthropology and the Indigenous Studies Program at McMaster University. Her research is grounded in the principle that solution-based research in the area of Indigenous health must occur alongside building capacity for community collaborations. She is the Principal Investigator for two Global Water Futures projects, Co-Creation of Indigenous Water Quality Tools, and Ohneganos—Water is Life. 

References

Adelson, N. (2005). The embodiment of inequity: Health Disparities in Aboriginal Canada. Canadian

Journal of Public Health 96: S45-S62.

Anderson, K., and Lawrence, B. (2003). Strong Women Stories: Native Vision and Community Survival.

(1st ed, Sumach Press).

Arquette, M., Cole, M., & Akwesasne Task Force on the Environment. (2004). Restoring Our

Relationships for the Future. In Blaser, M., Feit, H.A., and McRae, G. (eds) In the Way of Development: Indigenous Peoples, Life Projects, and Globalization . London: Zed pp. 332-350.

Baird, J., Carter, B., Cave, K., Dupont, D., General, P., King, C., Plummer, R., & Varewyck, A. (2013).

Gaining Insights about Water: The value of surveys in First Nations communities to inform water governance. Indigenous Policy Journal 23(4):1-18.

Ball, J. (2014). On Thin Ice: Managing Risks in Community-University Research Projects. In Learning

and Teaching Community-Based Research: Linking Pedagogy to Practice. Eds. C. Etmanski, B.L. Hall, and T. Dawson. Pp. 25-44.

Ball, J., & Jaynst, P. (2008). Enacting research ethics in partnerships with Indigenous communities in

Canada: “Do it in a good way.” Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 3(2):33-51.

Bunch, M.J., Morrison, K.E., Parkes, M.W., & Venema, H.D. (2011). Promoting Health and Wellbeing

by Managing for Socio-Ecological Resilience: the potential for integrating ecohealth and water resources management approaches. Ecology and Society 16(1):6

Burke, M., Gonzalez, F., Baylis, P., Heft-Neal, S., Baysan, C., Basu, S., & Hsiang, S. (2018). Higher

temperatures increase suicide rates in the United States and Mexico. Nature Climate Change 8: 723-729.

Castellano, M.B. (2000). Updating Aboriginal traditions of knowledge. In Indigenous Knowledges in

Global Contexts: Multiple Readings of our World. Hall, B.L., Jerry, G., Dei, S., and Rosenberg, D.G. (eds).

Chitewere, T., Schim, J.K., Barker, J.C., & Yen, I.H. (2017). How neighbourhoods influence health:

lessons to be learned from the application of political ecology. Health and Place 45:117-123.

Collins, AE. (2002). Health ecology and environmental management in Mozambique. Health and Place

(4):263-272.

Daes, E. I. (1994). UN Sub-commission on the promotion and protection of human rights, Protection

of the heritage of Indigenous people: preliminary report of the Special Rapporteur, Erica-Irene Daes, submitted in conformity with Sub-Comission resolution 1993/44 and decision 1994/105 of the Commission on Human Rights. 8 July 1994. Retrieved from: https://www.refworld.org/docid/3b00f25810.html

D’Alisa, G., Germani, A.R., Falcone, P.M., & Morone, P. (2017). Political ecology of health in the

Land of Fires: a hotspot of environmental crimes in the south of Italy. Journal of Political Ecology 24:59-86.

Deloria, VJ. (1995). Red Earth, White Lies: Native Americans and the Myth of Scientific Fact. Scribner,

New York, NY.

Drawson, A., Toombs, E., and Mushquash, C. (2017). Indigenous Research Methods: A systematic

review. The International Indigenous Policy Journal 8(2).

Eimer, T.R., & Bartels, T. (2019). From consent to consultation: Indigenous rights and the new

environmental constitutionalism. Environmental Politics, DOI: 10.1080/09644016.2019.1595884

First Nations Information Governance Centre (FNIGC). (2014). Ownership, Control, Accces, and

Possession (OCAP): The Path to First Nations Information Goverance. May 2014, Ottawa. Retrieved from: https://fnigc.ca/sites/default/files/docs/ocap_path_to_fn_information_governance_en_final.pdf.

Green, D., & Raygorodetsky, G. (2010). Indigenous knowledge of a changing climate. Climatic Change

(2):239-242.

Hallenbeck, J. (2015). Returning to the water to enact a treaty relationship: the Two Row Wampum

Renewal Campaign. Settler Colonial Studies 5(4): 350-362.

Hamacher, D.W. (2018). Observations of red-giant variable stars by Aboriginal Australians. The

Australian Journal of Anthropology 29(1):89-107.

Hunter, J. (2003). Inherited burden of disease: agricultural dams and the persistence of bloody urine

(Schistosomiasis hematobium) in the Upper West Region of Ghana, 1959-1997. Social Science and Medicine 56(2):219-234.

Indigenous Services Canada (2019). Ending long-term drinking water advisories. Retrieved at:

https://www.sac-isc.gc.ca/eng/1506514143353/1533317130660

Jackson, P., & Neely, AH. (2015). Triangulating health: Toward a practice of a political ecology of

health. Progress in Human Geography 39(1):47-64.

Jacobs, K.L. (1996). Towards renewed balance & harmony in the natural world: An environmental

responsibility protocol for Kahnawake Mohawk Territory and Beyond. Unpublished Masters Thesis, University of Guelph. Retrieved at: https://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk4/etd/MQ83334.PDF

King, B. (2010). Political ecologies of health. Progress in Human Geography 34:38-55.

King, J.T. (2007). Value of Water and the meaning of Water Law for the Native Americans Known as the

Haudenosaunee. Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 16:452.

Kuokkanen, R. (2015). Gendered Violence and Politics in Indigenous Communities. International

Feminist Journal of Politics 17(2):271-288.

Lawrence, B. (2004). Real Indians and Others: Mixed Blood Urban Native Peoples and Indigenous

Nationhood. UBC Press.

Leathermann, T. (2005). A space of vulnerability in poverty and health: Political-ecology and biocultural

analysis. Ethos 33(1):46-70.

Majeed, J. & Lee, H. (2017). The impact of climate change on youth depression and mental health. The

Lancet: Planetary Health 1:e94-e95.

Maracle, L. (2002). I am Woman: A Native Perspective on Sociology and Feminism. Global Professional

Publishing.

Marks, J. (2012). Why be against Darwin? Creationism, Racism, and the Roots of Anthropology.

Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 55:94-104.

Martin-Hill, D. (2009). Traditional Medicine and Restoration of Wellness Strategies. International

Journal of Indigenous Health 5(1):26-42.

Mayer, JD. (1996). The political ecology of disease as one new focus for medical geography. Progress in

Human Geography 20(4):441-456.

McCabe, G. (2008). Mind, body, emotions, and spirit: reaching to the ancestors for healing. Counselling

Psychology Quarterly 21(2):143-152.

McCarthy, J. (2002). First World political ecology: lessons from the Wise Use movement. Environment

and Planning A 34:1281-1302

McGregor, D. (2008). Linking traditional ecological knowledge and western science: Aboriginal

perspectives from the 2000 State of the Lakes Ecosystem conference. The Canadian Journal of Native Studies 28(1):139-158.

McGregor, D. (2012). Traditional Knowledge: Considerations for Protecting Water in Ontario. The

International Indigenous Policy Journal 3(3): 1-21.

Nesbitt, J.T., & Weiner, D. (2001). Conflicting environmental imaginaries and the politics of nature in

Central Appalachia. Geoforum 32(3):333-349.

Ransom, J.W. & Ettenger, K.T. (2001). ‘Polishing the Kaswentha’: a Haudenosaunee view of

environmental cooperation. Environmental Science & Policy 4:219-228.

Richmond, C., Elliot, SJ, Matthews, R., & Elliot, B. (2005). The political ecology of health: perceptions

of environment, economy, health and wellbeing among ‘Namgis First Nation. Health and Place 11:349-365.

Schnarch, B. (2004). Ownership, Control, Access, and Possession (OCAP) or Self-Determination Applied

to Research: A critical analysis of contemporary First Nations research and some option for First Nations communities. Journal of Aboriginal Health 1(1):80-95.

Schneider, L. (2013). ‘There’s Something in the Water’: Salmon Runs and Settler Colonialism on the

Columbia River. American Indian Culture and Research Journal 37(2):150.

Shimo, A. (2018). While Nestle extracts millions of litres from their land, residents have no drinking

water. The Guardian. Retrieved at: https://www.theguardian.com/global/2018/oct/04/ontario-six-nations-nestle-running-water?CMP=share_btn_fb&page=with%3Aimg-6#img-6

Shiva, V. (2000). Bioethics: A Third World Issue. Research Institute for Science, Technology, and

Ecology. India: New Delhi

Smedley, A., & Smedley, B.D. (2005). Race as Biology is Fiction, Racism as Social Problem is Real:

Anthropological and Historical Perspectives on the Social Construction of Race. American Psychologist 60(1):16-26.

Smith, L. (2005). Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples. London: Zed.

Sultana, F. (2012). Producing Contaminated Citizens: Toward a Nature—Society Geography of Health

and Well-Being. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 102(5):1165-1172.

Swain, H., Louttit, S., & Hrudey, S. (2006). Report of the expert panel on safe drinking water for First

Nations, Volume 1. Ottawa, ON: Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development.

Tuhiwai Smith, L. (2008). Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indiginous Peoples. University of

Otago Press, New Zealand.

Turshen, M. (1984). The Political Ecology of Disease in Tanzania. Rutgers University Press, New

Brunswick, NJ.

United Nations, (2018). The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2018. Retrieved at:

https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/report/2018/overview/

Warry, W. (1998). Unfinished Dreams: Community Healing and the Reality of Aboriginal Self-

Government. University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

Published
2020-10-27
How to Cite
Duignan, S., Moffat, T., & Martin-Hill, D. (2020). Using Boundary Objects to Co-Create Community Health and Water Knowledge with Community-Based Medical Anthropology and Indigenous Knowledge. Engaged Scholar Journal: Community-Engaged Research, Teaching, and Learning, 6(1), 49-76. https://doi.org/10.15402/esj.v6i1.68178